10399442 10205434923130401 7091154257100643638 n
Exclamation made by Miles at the end of each episode's cold open to express disbelief at the tangled web of continuity that Rachel has just articulated.

In early episodes, Jay occasionally made the exclamation while Miles explained, but in later episodes, the WHAT?! has been solely the domain of Miles.

In guest episodes, Jay and Miles typically deliver the WHAT?! in unison.